top of page
junior-pavilion.jpg

MEET THE
JUDGES.

The 2026 Southeast judges.

AN ADDITION FROM EMILY GRACE

 

Jacob’s article explains why we chose a Scottish judge. I want to share what came out of that decision.

 

For years, I’ve heard people in the Highland breed complain that we need Scottish judges, that American shows are changing the breed and we’re losing traditional Highland character. Well, if that’s true, shouldn’t we do something about it? And if it’s not, what does it hurt to bring in a different perspective?

 

Bringing Iain MacKay to the Southeast gave us an opportunity to compare what we’re doing here with what’s happening in Scotland. People watched from around the world, and the Highland Cattle Society shared our event. But I was so busy working that I barely got to watch the show myself.

 

My chance to really learn from Iain came over breakfast with him and Claire the next morning, before rushing back to clean up the fairgrounds. Once we started talking, I didn’t want it to end. Hearing about their farm at Torloisk on the Isle of Mull and seeing photos helped me understand why he looks for the things he does.

 

His cattle range over thousands of acres of rough hill ground in a wet, exposed landscape. They have to climb hillsides, find grazing, and stay sound enough to keep doing it for years. Suddenly, his dislike of overly fat cattle made more sense to me. Those animals still have a job to do, and carrying extra weight doesn’t help.

 

He talked about bulls still breeding into their late teens and cows having calves into their early twenties. He told me his heifers first calve around four years old, with calves weighing roughly 70 pounds, and that they rarely need assistance. They help when it’s needed, because animal welfare comes first, but they’re strict about which animals they breed again.

 

That got me thinking about my own cattle. As Highland prices go up, how often do we justify breeding a cow with recurring problems because her next calf is worth so much? One difficult birth doesn’t tell the whole story, and not every problem is inherited. But repeatedly helping an animal stay productive shouldn’t keep us from questioning whether we ought to pass those traits on.

 

I love watching cattle shows, but I also want to know what an animal and its family have done outside the ring. Did its mother calve easily, raise good calves, and stay sound into old age? Can the bull keep settling cows year after year? A ribbon can’t answer all of that.

 

It was encouraging to hear that Iain and Claire felt plenty of cattle at our show could do well in their environment. They also thought several sale animals would have done well in the show and wished they’d been entered. In their email afterward, they described temperament and gut capacity as two strengths they noticed in our show cattle compared with those at Oban.

 

We have things to learn from Scotland, but they also saw what we’re doing well here. Neither country has everything figured out, and talking openly about both our strengths and our concerns is part of what made their visit worthwhile.

 

I’d heard concerns about heritage breeds becoming one “mono-breed,” but my main concern had been the miniature cattle market. This conversation helped me understand that we can keep the hair and horns while losing the abilities that made Highlands distinct. These cattle weren’t developed to win ribbons, and their traditional qualities matter for good reasons.

 

That’s the kind of conversation I want the Southeast to encourage. Seeing the kids involved, older youth helping younger exhibitors, and adults volunteering and donating to make it happen gave me hope for the breed’s future. I hope we can help these kids understand that caring for their cattle, helping each other, and preserving the breed matter long after the ribbons are handed out.

 

Claire also shared her paper, “Conservation genetics and the stewardship of the Highland breed,” with me. I got a great video interview with Iain that I’ll eventually share on Happy Hens & Highlands, and the Southeast will be posting more from the event, so stay tuned.

 

We hope to see you at the Southeast next year.

 

Emily Grace, Southeast Highland Cattle Show & Sale

bottom of page